Question:
OK, OK, OK..florida bass fish large small tip… I *am* writing this because of the winner at Westminster!
Thank doG that the Goldens never win at Westminster!!! national club from AKC and couldn’t get ahold of the breeder contact person tonight and will try again tomorrow.florida bass fish large small tip Showing them isn’t a big concern, but it would be nice to have a pair of good pets to help proliferate this breed in America. (I’ve seen some breeders who list prices for show stock and
Oh boy. Well,florida bass fish large small tip the Clumber drools, chews, eats everything in sight (a canine vacuum cleaner), sheds and sheds white fur ALL OVER everything, is selectively deaf, can not be forced to do anything that it doesn’t want to do. In 1993 140 Clumbers were registered with the AKC. Waiting lists for puppies are VERY VERY long.florida bass fish large small tip It will probably be a cold day in hell before a Clumber breeder sells a breeding pair to someone who wants to not show yet “help proliferate this breed in America”. Clumbers are prone to fungal foot infections, snore, have problems with underbites, ectropion and have a risk of disk problems and dysplasia. It MUST be an inside dog, and is a real high maintenance one at that. You can not leave a Clumber in the yard hoping it will amuse itself. It won’t. And it won’t self exercise either like some sportings dogs will. They have a tiny gene pool and anyone breeding them really has to know what he is doing. The risks of not knowing squat about genetics and breeding a dog like this are huge. In short,florida bass fish large small tip if you do your research, you could probably get on a waiting list for ***A*** pet puppy, one who will have to be neutered, and never bred. To think that any Clumber breeder is going to set you up as a back yard breeder is really showing how little you know about the breed. It is such an unusual breed that I am willing to bet that you have never met one, let alone spent any time with one. But based on a win at Westminster, florida bass fish large small tip you’re ready to go into the breeding business. How on earth would you be able to tell if you are breeding correct dogs or not? As if you would care. Ann, Twzl & Sligo –
Response:
Well said!!!!!! I have a pet female (spayed) Clumber that I waited a VERY long time for. She (of course) is the best dog in the world. However she has the typical Clumber health problems.florida bass fish large small tip Both eyes were ectropic which cost $1000.00 to fix. She snores like a banshee… I can’t even keep her in my bedroom with my other dog. She gets “stiff” after long walks and will find any speck of garbage within a 100 miles. However, I knew of these problems prior to getting her and I wouldn’t sell her for a billion dollars. I also would not breed Clumbers for a billion dollars.florida bass fish large small tip Kudos to all the breeders out there who are struggling to make this dog healthier. Best of Luck George Hejna
Response:
We have a Clumber which we obtained through a rescue league. She is spoiled and very affectionate. She think’s she’s a lap dog, which can be tough if you are wearing a dark sweater or pants. She doesn’t drool, but does snore, she will find things to chew, and always finds discarded food along our walks (and will swollow it before we can get it out of her mouth). We got lucky and didn’t have to wait long, but I imagine lists are beginning to grow. She is not a guard dog. If we put her in the back yard, she’ll sit until someone comes out, or climb over the fence into the neighboring yard. A contact for the Clumber Spaniel Rescue Committee is Sue Carr (908) 580-1055.
Response:
My understanding from the research that I have done it that waiting list for a good quality Clumber from a reputable breeder is 2-4 years long. As to the comment on getting a good pair of pets to proliferate the breed, the reason there aren’t many, is the breeders control the numbers and are very particular to who they will sell puppies to. One breeder I know of finishes her puppies before she places. Good luck in your quest. Theresa Mom to Bogie and the rest of the mastiff horde and Hannah (the Rottie), too
Response:
tonight and will try again tomorrow. Showing them isn’t a big concern, but it would be nice to have a pair of good pets to help proliferate this breed in America. (I’ve seen some breeders who list prices for show stock and for puppies are VERY VERY long. It will probably be a cold day in hell before a Clumber breeder sells a breeding pair to someone who wants to not show yet “help proliferate this breed in America”.
To think that any Clumber breeder is going to set you up as a back yard breeder is really showing how little you know about the breed. It is such an unusual breed that I am willing to bet that you have never met one, let alone spent any time with one. But based on a win at Westminster, you’re ready to go into the breeding business. How on earth would you be able to tell if you are breeding correct dogs or not? As if you would care.
I sketched one at a dog show once, and my first ESS’s breeder gave up Springers for Clumbers. AND there were a couple being shown in Hawaii when I lived there. Good heavens, I’m a BREED EXPERT and didn’t know it!! I’ll make MILLIONS! There’ll be a Clumber in Every Pet Shop! Needless to say, the Clumber people are Not Happy with potentially having the newest “hot” breed… Linda and Brandy CGC (English Shepherd) and the ESS: Maggie and Clancy
Response:
I sketched one at a dog show once, and my first ESS’s breeder gave up Springers for Clumbers. AND there were a couple being shown in Hawaii when I lived there. Good heavens, I’m a BREED EXPERT and didn’t know it!! I’ll make MILLIONS! There’ll be a Clumber in Every Pet Shop!
Hey, and I responded to you, so you better split those millions, ok? I want a piece of the action!!!!!
Ann, Twzl & Sligo who are always very, very glad that the Goldens never win –
Response:
OK, OK, OK….. I *am* writing this because of the winner at Westminster! Thank doG that the Goldens never win at Westminster!!! national club from AKC and couldn’t get ahold of the breeder contact person tonight and will try again tomorrow. Showing them isn’t a big concern, but it would be nice to have a pair of good pets to help proliferate this breed in America. (I’ve seen some breeders who list prices for show stock and Oh boy. Well, the Clumber drools, chews, eats everything in sight (a canine vacuum cleaner), sheds and sheds white fur ALL OVER everything, is selectively deaf, can not be forced to do anything that it doesn’t want to do.
So, other than the drooling and shedding part, their attitude is similar to a ferret! :) They also constantly have things in their mouth, such as one dog who decided that a toy strawberry was the coolest thing in the world and would bathe, run, play, and go to the toilet…with the strawberry in her mouth. In 1993 140 Clumbers were registered with the AKC.
…with quite a few of those litters being single pup litters! Waiting lists for puppies are VERY VERY long. It will probably be a cold day in hell before a Clumber breeder sells a breeding pair to someone who wants to not show yet “help proliferate this breed in America”.
Ya see…that’s *why* I asked. When I spoke with some breeders about Lundehunds (the rarest breed in the world), they were interested in helping others learn to breed them (and what dogs do *not* make good breeders) and explained the guidelines to avoid the genetic problems due to their much smaller gene pool. The breeders for Lundehundes and Clumbers have both been very helpful and want to tell you everything about them, including aspects of breeding and genetics. As Ms. Carr told me, “You should never have to worm any information out of a breeder. If they don’t want to tell you something, you don’t want to buy from them.” They have a tiny gene pool and anyone breeding them really has to know what he is doing. The risks of not knowing squat about genetics and breeding a dog like this are huge.
Like the fact that you have to feed them every two hours for the first three weeks of their life because the mothers tend to accidentally suffocate them or the fact that their gene pool is so small primarily because the Duke of Windsor’s (?) Son ordered all of his father’s dogs to be killed upon his death. In short, if you do your research, you could probably get on a waiting list for ***A*** pet puppy, one who will have to be neutered, and never bred. To think that any Clumber breeder is going to set you up as a back yard breeder is really showing how little you know about the breed.
Or, the fact that I *asked questions* in a post to this newsgroup just MIGHT be a clue that I did not (at the time) know much about the specifics of clumber spaniels. But please, inflate your own ego by restating the obvious. That’s why I asked the questions and why I’ve spent over an hour on the phone (so far) researching a breed of dog that we would not be ready for some months to come. That’s also the reason why we’ll be driving for about five hours one way to visit the nearest breeder just so we can see the dogs and spend time with them, even though we might never be able to have one. But, as you’ve already descerned, I’m just an uncaring bastard who doesn’t want his animal charges to be healthy or happy. You’ve caught me, just as I was pouring the concrete slabs in the back yard for my first puppy mill. If it weren’t for responses like this, imagine the terrible lives that all those thousands of puppies that I could crank out would have! You are truly a saviour sent directly from heaven! It is such an unusual breed that I am willing to bet that you have never met one, let alone spent any time with one.
See above. But based on a win at Westminster, you’re ready to go into the breeding business.
Oh I forget, this is the ‘net, where you can write anything without actually having to speak to the person. I did *not* realize asking questions was such a terrible thing. Of course, (and thank you for pointing this out) a TRULY responsible pet owner would NEVER ask questions about breeding because “You couldn’t do it, so you just don’t need to know.” Thanks to you, I now realize that breeding is a subject that you should remain completely ignorant about. How on earth would you be able to tell if you are breeding correct dogs or not?
Well, since you’ve found me out and thwarted my plans for the billion dollar a year puppy mill, my best guess is “If’n they live until you sell ‘em, then dem dere is good dawgs.” I would like to humbly thank the all knowing Oracle for doling out this apparently sacred information to a mere mortal, such as I. However, none of the information you graciously provided above is “new” to me (I’ve known it since last Saturday). Hopefully, this isn’t *all* of your knowledge about the breed, as it would appear that I know a few things more than you….therefore, your condescending, holier than thou response was a waste of your time. As if you would care.
Yes, I might just care so much about these beautiful dogs that I will spend close to $100 and several hours of my time just to learn information about a dog that we might not be able get for years to come. So, please, everyone else who might want to actually research an animal before you buy one, don’t ask about breeding!!!! This apparently is not encouraged and you should just remain completely unknowledgable about this area. PS: To all those who have provided me with information in a civil form, a heart felt thanks from my wife and myself! We have certainly learned a lot about these lovable creatures.
Response:
Ya see…that’s *why* I asked. When I spoke with some breeders about Lundehunds (the rarest breed in the world), they were interested in helping
Do you decide what dog to buy based on how rare it is? Or, the fact that I *asked questions* in a post to this newsgroup just MIGHT be a clue that I did not (at the time) know much about the specifics of clumber spaniels. But please, inflate your own ego by restating the obvious.
You said, in your first post, “I saw the Clumber on Westminster, and now I want to breed them”. Do you honestly think that anyone would take such a person to be a serious student of the breed or of breeding dogs? That’s why I asked the questions and why I’ve spent over an hour on the phone (so far) researching a breed of dog that we would not be ready for
A whole hour!! Wow, that’s longer than watching an epsiode of Home Improvement. five hours one way to visit the nearest breeder just so we can see the dogs and spend time with them, even though we might never be able to have one.
People who breed dogs and do a good job of it, usually start off liking dogs, working them or showing them or both, and then, after a few years decide if their dogs are worth breeding. Few people that do a good job start off with the assumption that no matter what they want to breed. know.” Thanks to you, I now realize that breeding is a subject that you should remain completely ignorant about.
Nope. See above. The problem is, if you start off with the assumption of “I own a purebred dog therefore I will breed it”, you are really making a big mistake. And you still didn’t answer my question of how you will know if you are breeding correct dogs or not. You’re like a person I know of who just had a litter of puppies, and has never been to a dog show. How on earth can she know if her bitch met the breed standard??? the information you graciously provided above is “new” to me (I’ve known it since last Saturday). Hopefully, this isn’t *all* of your knowledge about the breed, as it would appear that I know a few things more than you….therefore, your condescending, holier than thou response was a waste of your time.
I don’t know about that: I got thank you notes from Clumber breeders, so I think I did a good job. And as far as knowing all of this since last Saturday, that statement alone should tip off anyone that you are not ready to get involved in dog breeding. Try spending a few years in dog sports, and then see if you want to breed. I think on average people spend about 5 years showing dogs before many of them ditch it for golf or whatever…I would hate to see Clumber rescue busy with your dogs a few years from now. Yes, I might just care so much about these beautiful dogs that I will spend close to $100 and several hours of my time just to learn information about a dog that we might not be able get for years to come.
You SHOULD be spending time and money on research. If nothing else, you will know if the puppy you get is breeding material or not. If your only exposure to the breed is 45 seconds on TV and a half hour visit to a breeder, what do you know? Why not make plans to go to the next Clumber specialty or supported entry, and take a look at a ring filled with them. Do taht a few times, and you might start to learn how to pick a puppy, and if that puppy is worthy of bring bred. So, please, everyone else who might want to actually research an animal before you buy one, don’t ask about breeding!!!! This apparently is not encouraged and you should just remain completely unknowledgable about this
Why would you want to buy a dog, just for the purpose of breeding? To me this is just so ass-backwards. Buy a dog because you want an obedience partner, a hunting dog, a show dog, a pet, but don’t buy one to breed. If your dog DOES turn out good enough to breed, that’s great. But to buy an 8 week old puppy just because YOU want to breed dogs, is really silly. What if the puppy turns 2 and has some disqualifying trait? And can never be bred? Do you then toss it away? Some people do, which is why when I hear of people buying a puppy just because they want to breed dogs one day, I get worried. Lots can happen between 8 weeks and an age at which a dog can be bred. And if your only investment in that dog is that you want a litter it’s too easy to dump the dog for your next one. Spend some time talking to breeders who wind up with 7 or 8 neutered pets, dogs that were meant to be the start of their breeding lines, and wound up never to have a single puppy. Ann, Twzl & Sligo –
Response:
I haven’t caught this whole thread, but I have just a few comments, first about why you got flamed Jason, then about Clumbers. First, you set yourself up as major flambait right away by stating that you weren’t interested in anything but pets, no showing. Responsible breeders are quite interested in *all* facets of their breed. They want to make sure the dog is able to do the job it was bred to do, is genetically free of disease (as much as is possible), and they want to make sure the dog looks like the breed it is supposed to be. I’m not accusing you of anything, but by saying you are not interested in showing, you put yourself very firmly, in some minds, into the backyard breeder category–the person who wants to have puppies and make a bit of money without doing the extensive research required for the breed. You say that you have spent a whole hour on the phone (big wow) and may spend as much as $100 researching this breed before you are through. When you say this to people who have spent *years* and many *thousands* of dollars researching, doing genetic testing, showing and training their dogs, you show yourself to be a complete amateur. You are right, you cannot learn without first being willing to start to learn, but please realize that the people on this group are not only trying to educate you, but also trying to discourage all those other people out there who fall in “instant love” with the breed that wins Westminster and suddenly decide they must breed it. Each and every time this has happened in the past, it has resulted in great detriment to the breed, the Cocker and the Doberman being 2 good examples of what happens when “popularity” hits the breed. There are still good representatives of both out there, but they are overwhelmed by the masses of incorrect, too large, bad temperamented dogs that can’t do what they were supposed to do and are plagued with a multitude of genetic faults. Which brings me to the next point about Clumbers. No one has mentioned yet the prevalence of Hip Dysplasia in Clumber Spaniels. The following information is re-printed with permission from the Orthopedic Foundation for Animals pamphlet, “Hip Dysplasia”, copyright OFA. Of 100 breeds with at least 100 evaluations between January 1974 and January 1995, Clumbers rank number *3*. There have been 124 Clumber evaluations. Of those, only 2.4% were considered Excellent. A whopping 52.4% were dysplastic. The only 2 breeds worse off than Clumbers are the Otterhound and the Bulldog. *If* after you spend your big $100 on all your research you decide that you must breed these dogs, I certainly hope you are willing to spend the $1000’s it will take to do the hip operations on the dogs you get which are dysplastic. — Robin Nuttall (my opinions are mine, nobody else wants them anyway) Doberman page: http://www.hsc.missouri.edu/people/robin/rjntp.html Abby’s rescue page: http://www.hsc.missouri.edu/people/robin/abby.html
Response:
: Thank doG that the Goldens never win at Westminster!!! Nor should they! Anyone who would want to vacumn twice a day, groom 7 days a week, put up with their constant drooling, have a “watchdog” that won’t watch, exercise at least 3 hours a day and still have the dog running with wild abandon throughout the house knocking off lamps etc would need their head examined. Not to mention the HUGH vet bills for HD.. constant hot spots.. tennis- ball-ectomies. Think again folks… Dixie Lee and Amber Lee
… there, maybe that moved us down on the most-popular breed list a tad (oh please!!!)
Response:
I haven’t caught this whole thread, but I have just a few comments, first about why you got flamed Jason, then about Clumbers. First, you set yourself up as major flambait right away by stating that you weren’t interested in anything but pets, no showing. Responsible breeders are quite interested in *all* facets of their breed. They want to make sure the dog is able to do the job it was bred to do, is genetically free of disease (as much as is possible), and they want to make sure the dog looks like the breed it is supposed to be.
I fully understand that, however there (to the best of my knowledge) has never been a dog show in my town. The closest city that could support one would probably be Tulsa, Oklahoma (to which, I would gladly go, if I did not have to work). Next time, I will qualify myself with the statement, “I am not a doctor, nor do I play one on TV, therefore I don’t have tens of thousands of dollars to spend flying a pet around the country to every show.” Do you think that will help explain my position? Why does the AKC accept so many papers on dogs that will never be shown if showing is so important? Truth be told, any time my wife and I talk about winning the lottery and our dreams if we did, I always say that I would like to buy a big farm and devote my entire time to raising special animals. With an unlimited money supply, you could provide every single need and have it all be perfect…and get to spend hours a day watching your “children” grow and multiply. I’m not accusing you of anything, but by saying you are not interested in showing, you put yourself very firmly, in some minds, into the backyard breeder category–the person who wants to have puppies and make a bit of money without doing the extensive research required for the breed.
As I stated, from my prior experience researching Norwegian Lundehunds (a far, far rarer breed than clumber with a much smaller gene pool), I assumed that clumber owners would be just as receptive to someone interested in A) learning everything about the breed and B) breeding the breed, if feasible. Lundehund breeders actually *want* their breed to expand its number and, therefore, survive and will do anything to help you understand the why/what/who/how about doing that. From what Sue Carr told me, so will clumber breeders. One even called her on Christmas to see how a puppy was doing! Sue said that she knew who the “bad” breeders were and would not recommend them and to call her for a reference if I stumbled across someone with clumbers. So, my assumption was incorrect. Part of what draws me towards clumbers and lundehunds (and VW Beetles, ferrets, and the Amiga personal computer) is the fact they are beautiful and quite unique and *not* something that everybody else on the planet has. You say that you have spent a whole hour on the phone (big wow) and may spend as much as $100 researching this breed before you are through. When you say this to people who have spent *years* and many *thousands* of dollars researching, doing genetic testing, showing and training their dogs, you show yourself to be a complete amateur.
Funny thing, I guess the fact that I was asking for information about the breed wasn’t a big clue that I’m an amateur???? It would be entirely different if I were like some people who post to rec.pets.herp and say “I just bought these two veiled chameleons and am keeping them in a five gallon plastic bucket. Why aren’t they breeding yet?” I don’t have a clumber (yet), but still people are acting as if there are two clumbers in my front room and I’m holding a shotgun to their heads saying “If you don’t breed and start paying for yourselves REAL SOON….” You are right, you cannot learn without first being willing to start to learn,
And getting negative responses like the ones I have certainly does encourage an educational and informative environment, doesn’t it? but please realize that the people on this group are not only trying to educate you, but also trying to discourage all those other people out there who fall in “instant love” with the breed that wins Westminster and suddenly decide they must breed it.
The last time I checked, mine was the ONLY post about clumbers on USENET. Sure, thousands of people in the country now know what clumber spaniel should look like. Thousands of people now want one because they’re “cute”. Hundreds of people have gone to their pet store and asked how much a clumber spaniel was and when they could pick one up. Now, call me crazy, but I’ll bet there are very few people who are fully investigating every need and nuance of this particular breed to help them evaluate whether this breed is the right one for them. For some reason, I don’t feel that what I am doing is quite the same as asking “Now, how big will this thing get?” while I’m signing the check to the pet store. Each and every time this has happened in the past, it has resulted in great detriment to the breed, the Cocker and the Doberman being 2 good examples of what happens when “popularity” hits the breed. There are still good representatives of both out there, but they are overwhelmed by the masses of incorrect, too large, bad temperamented dogs that can’t do what they were supposed to do and are plagued with a multitude of genetic faults. Which brings me to the next point about Clumbers. No one has mentioned yet the prevalence of Hip Dysplasia in Clumber Spaniels.
Yes, Sue Carr, chairwoman of the Clumber Spaniel Rescue Committee, mentioned that to me. She did not give me the reference you listed below (and thank you for the citation), but did mention hip dysplasia’s prevelance with clumbers. Since this was towards the end of our conversation, I made a note to get more information about it the next time I spoke with her or a clumber breeder. Your reference does re-emphasize the importance of getting more info on it. Thank you. The following information is re-printed with permission from the Orthopedic Foundation for Animals pamphlet, “Hip Dysplasia”, copyright OFA. Of 100 breeds with at least 100 evaluations between January 1974 and January 1995, Clumbers rank number *3*. There have been 124 Clumber evaluations. Of those, only 2.4% were considered Excellent. A whopping 52.4% were dysplastic. The only 2 breeds worse off than Clumbers are the Otterhound and the Bulldog.
Could you also send the ranking of the prevalance of hip dysplasia with bassett hounds? My wife’s family keeps them and I would appreciate it. *If* after you spend your big $100 on all your research you decide that you must breed these dogs,
Apparently, my first post was poorly phrased, but I thought my reply, albeit defensive, made it clear what my primary goals are. You (along with several others reading my post) think that I am researching how to breed clumber spaniels. That is *not* true. Here are my goals in this research, arranged in order of importance. Hopefully this will clear all doubt as to *my* intentions. Your negative use of the adjective “big” belittles my monetary and emotional investment in doing research about this breed. Obviously, you have decided that whatever I do, it will be inadequate and meaningless. While your feelings regarding me are not accurate, they are still your feelings and I doubt they will change. Perhaps you should contact the owners of the two clumbers that Ms. Carr placed with a pair of brothers. She said they had not been outside of a kennel in three years and were former “show dogs”. They had forgotten how to play, how to run on grass, and generally, how to be dogs. It broke my heart to hear that someone could take these special animals so frivilously! How could someone do that to any animal, let alone these unique creatures? That breeder obviously knew how important a show is…to the monetary value, anyway. Sue visited the dogs three months later and didn’t recognize them. They were as active and happy as any clumber! It is certainly a testament to the strong, happy spirit of this breed. GOAL: To obtain all available information about clumber spaniels to satisfy my and my wife’s intense curiosity about this beautiful breed. This information will help us to make the following decisions: A) Would a clumber spaniel would make a good pet? B) What kind of pet would a clumber be? What is their personality like? C) Would our lifestyle enable us to provide a proper home for a clumber? D) After spending time around one, would we still want to have one as a pet? E) Would a clumber be compatible with our other pets? F) What are their breeding and rearing requirements? G) Is breeding something that we would want to pursue now? H) Is breeding something that we would want to pursue later in life? Those questions aren’t from any book on pets. Those are the questions that I ask myself about any pet whether it is a ferret, dog, bird, reptile, or fish. Those steps really work. So far, the only pet that has made it all the way to question G is the betta (or Siamese fighting fish). (And, yes, they spawned successfully and we raised over 20 beautiful fish. It was a beautiful process to watch, too!) Now, I am *not* saying that because I bred fish, that I can breed clumber spaniels. Only an idiot would make that assumption. However, the reason that we were successfully (well, the fish, actually, not us) is the fact that we DID THE RESEARCH and knew the what we were getting into. I certainly hope you are willing to spend the $1000’s it will take to do the hip operations on the dogs you get which are dysplastic.
If anyone breeds clumbers, they had damn well better be ready to do so! – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text — Robin Nuttall (my opinions are mine, nobody else wants them anyway) Doberman page: http://www.hsc.missouri.edu/people/robin/rjntp.html Abby’s rescue page:
… read more »
Response:
Nor should they! Anyone who would want to vacumn twice a day, groom 7 days a week, put up with their constant drooling, have a “watchdog” that won’t watch, exercise at least 3 hours a day and still have the dog running with wild abandon throughout the house knocking off lamps etc would need their head examined.
Yes!!! And let’s review that shedding again…don’t let anyone tell you that Goldens shed twice a year. Around here a year is about a week long I guess, as the shedding is always going on. And the muddy paws…when it’s raining and really disgusting out your dog will want to go out, get all gross, come in and run all over the house with muddy paws. And then it will be time to go out again. None of this run out, pee and run back in. Oh no. It’s go out, leisurely go through each and every bog that has sprung up in the back yard, eat some dead bird that has arisen from the melting snow banks, come in, and hop on the couch. And then squeek a toy over and over and over again until none of the humans can possibly sleep late. Goldens? Feh!! Ann, Twzl & Sligo (she hates us) –
Response:
never been a dog show in my town. The closest city that could support one would probably be Tulsa, Oklahoma (to which, I would gladly go, if I did
How far is Tulsa from your town? I ask because it’s pretty typical for dog people to drive 2 or 3 hours or more to a show. I know that Tulsa does have quite a few shows, and you probably should make the time to go to one if you really want to meet Clumber breeders. And as far as not going to a dog show but wanting to breed…the AKC has some pretty rigid standards for what dogs of various breeds should look like. If you want to breed dogs, you owe it to the breed to see that YOUR dogs meet the standard. The only way to really do this is to show them. Otherwise, you are working in a vacuum. Yes, you may own the most beautiful Faxelhund in the world, but until it is in a ring with other Faxelhunds, you have no idea if it really looks like a Faxelhund. The last time I checked, mine was the ONLY post about clumbers on USENET. Sure, thousands of people in the country now know what clumber
No. Do you get rec.hunting.dogs at your site? There have been some posts there as well. Now, call me crazy, but I’ll bet there are very few people who are fully investigating every need and nuance of this particular breed to help them evaluate whether this breed is the right one for them. For some reason, I
I don’t know about gecko’s, but with dogs, most people do not breed. And someone looking for a pet of a breed they have never owned, and who freely admit they have no intention of ever even going to watch a dog show, is not someone who should be discovering the wonderful world of dog breeding. That’s all backwards. Spend a few years learning about the breed, belonging to the breed club, going to specialties, reading everything you can on the breed, talking to people who have owned, showed, hunted with and bred them. After a few years of this, you might then have an idea if you are cut out for dog breeding. If you are going to be a breeder, you probably will never breed your first dog: but by the second or third you might know enough to maybe think about it. F) What are their breeding and rearing requirements? G) Is breeding something that we would want to pursue now? H) Is breeding something that we would want to pursue later in life?
See? Again, they are not like fish. It’s unlikely that as a new Clumber owner you are going to wind up with a dog worth breeding. You may get fourth pick male, a pet, and if it is a pet, then he’s not something to keep in the gene pool. You have to understand that if you are not a working or show home, that although you may certainly wind up with a Clumber, it will be with all sorts of strings with regards to breeding. It’s like that in any breed where some breeders care about the breed. Ann, Twzl & Sligo –
Response:
Nor should they! Anyone who would want to vacumn twice a day, groom 7 days a week, put up with their constant drooling, have a “watchdog” that won’t watch, exercise at least 3 hours a day and still have the dog running with wild abandon throughout the house knocking off lamps etc would need their head examined.
AND, don’t forget the most endearing (NOT!) trait of all…rolling in stinky stuff. Sure, any dog might do this, but it seems to me that the sporting breeds, and Goldens in particular, seem to relish this more than most. And, with their coats, anything they roll in has to be BATHED out – you can’t wait till it dries and brush it off, like maybe you could do with a German Shorthair poinster, for instance. Emily
Response:
We all have your number and the waitung list just went to 25 years and the price 1,000,000,000! I waited for three years and I have been in dogs 26 and am a seasoned dog owner/handler and obedience trainer. I had to supply references and get checked out. I wasn’t put off for as an educated dog person I respected this attitude of responsibility and integrety. As an owner now of six Clumbers as I have been in the breed 10 years, I hope their gene pool now gets smaller just to keep them out of the hands of backyard breeders, puppymillers, money hungry, fad and impulse buyers. Clumbers are not for everyone and as all dogs shouldn’t be treated as a commodity. P.S. we don’t breed Pets as aside being a companion animal, the name actually refers to those dogs not suited to be bred. In addition all Clumbers are owners are thouroughly screened, put on a waiting list, and all dogs regardless of pet or show are sold with contracts and show quality one’s not outright and co-owned with the breeders. With the Westminster win, the lists have gotten longer, the prices have gone up, and the breeders now even paying attention more so as not to let these dogs get in the wrong hands. More dog breeds should be so lucky.
Response:
I have a pet female (spayed) Clumber that I waited a VERY long time for. She (of course) is the best dog in the world. However she has the typical Clumber health problems. Both eyes were ectropic which cost $1000.00 to fix.
Is this the problem when one eyelid is rolled up? Could you please give me a few more details about it? I asked a breeder about this and she said that she had one pup in her years of breeding and it was only $100 (a hundred) to fix.
Response:
BOTH upper and lower eyelids on BOTH eyes were rolling in and scratching her eyes. I will admit that a we used an eye specialist to do the surgery so the cost was probably inflated, but my mother had it done on her Golden by the local vet (who is an excellent vet) an the specialist did a MUCH better job so I think it was worth it. I also think it noteworthy to mention that this Clumber is not that well bred. The breeder no longer breeds Clumbers and I am glad that she stopped as are other Clumber breeders. George Presently looking for a Sussex Spaniel
Response:
We all have your number and the waitung list just went to 25 years and the price 1,000,000,000! With the Westminster win, the lists have gotten longer, the prices have gone up, and the breeders now even paying attention more so as not to let these dogs get in the wrong hands. More dog breeds should be so lucky.
And, Sue Carr (the chairperson of the Clumber Spaniel Rescue Committee) will NOT recommend any breeder who raises their prices because of the win at Westminster! According to a conversation with her, “The dogs don’t cost any more to breed since Westminster and anyone who raises their prices isn’t worth my reference.” I thought clumber breeders did it because of their love of the dog and not the love of money. Ironically, Sue also said that Brady’s breeder didn’t raise his prices. Personally, I find that a bit hard to swallow, but still believe it.
Response:
George: When the eyelids roll in that’s entropian ,not ectropian(when eyelids roll out).Just a piece of information,in case you need it in the future.Hope not for your sake.By the way,eye problems are never really bred out in a dog.You try to breed to good eyes,but usually entropian and ectropian have more to do with the head’s configuration on a dog than the eyes themselves. When puppies are young,as long as the eyelids and lashes are not rubbing the eye itself(and causing corneal ulcers),then it’s pretty safe to let it go.Most often,eyes will improve,providing they have minor entropian,when the heads broaden out nearing maturity. By the way I am a Clumber owner,show person and soon to be breeder.
Response:
Ya see…that’s *why* I asked. When I spoke with some breeders about Lundehunds (the rarest breed in the world), they were interested in helping Do you decide what dog to buy based on how rare it is?
No, I investigate breeds of dogs based upon my interest in them. I didn’t know that was a crime. Since there’s something obviously wrong with that, I think I’ll just stick to picking up mutts off the street. Would that meet with your seal of approval? If you had read the rest of my responses, you would know how I select pets. Please, continue with your selective reading and forget any of the important parts, so you won’t have to bother with them. It’ll make life much easier for you. You said, in your first post, “I saw the Clumber on Westminster, and now I want to breed them”.
By your use of quotation marks, you are implying that those are words that I entered. Since, I did *not* write the above phrase, please do not try and attribute it to me. If you read the above phrase from another post, please attribute it to the correct author. By the way, I have the name and number of the breeder that I will be visiting this weekend. I’m sure she would love to hear your thoughts about buying a clumber spaniel without spending at least 120 hours in their company. (Since you mentioned that hours of research and spending a day at a breeders isn’t enough time to decide if a clumber is the right dog for my family.) One reason that you should really talk to her is the fact that she decided she had to have a clumber after seeing pictures in a book. It would probably be most elightening for you to tell her how bad this was and how she should spend at least half of her life around clumbers before deciding whether or not she should own one. Then, she could tell you about all of her dogs, especially the one that was #2 clumber spaniel in the United States. Please, please take the time to actually read my responses before replying. It has been well stated that breeding is *not* of high importance to me. In your latest response, you mentioned “my dogs” or some reference to me breeding clumbers a total of four times. If you cannot see the fact that breeding is last on my list of importance, please stop responding, as I’m getting tired of saying it. I’m merely asking about breeding because it *is* part of owning a dog and to avoid the issue because it might offend you would be leaving a serious hole in my knowledge of clumbers. Once again, if you cannot see the fact that breeding is *last* on my list of importance, STOP responding and wasting my time and yours. If you get a chance, I’d really like the email addresses of all those breeders with whom you’ve communicated (or I would like for them to contact me directly, since they are all reading this message thread) , as it would help me immensely in my research. (Especially, since I’ve not received a single message from anyone who actually breed clumbers.) Thanks for your time. jwc
Response:
I beg to differ the prices are and have gone up. Do you know what it takes to raise a litter of Clumbers, they are not like any breed to raise. They are very delicate and are prone to Parvo, bitches usually have to have a Cesarian section, people are usually up all night with them as mothers tend to squash and smother their young, and there are numerous vet bills involved inorder to keep them healthy. The price is expensive because they are expensive to raise and for the most part they don’t even have large litters. They usually require special whelping boxes and many don’t make it through the first week. Breeding Clumbers is not for the novice and many people I know breed one litter and that’s it as the work and expense is tremendous. And even with the prices raised one never gets back what they put in. And furthermore as a good personal friend of Brady’s breeder his pups are some of the most costly out there and he keeps most of them himself, and the others are on a co-ownership basis, as most Clumber breeders have, and the price is still the same. Incidentally Sue Carr called me tonight and I know the score. Also one basically can never pick or choose a Clumber pup. You take what they have to offer you and that’s it.
Response:
Yea right again. This is very common due to the folds of loose skin and heavy brown causing the eyelashes to turn in, thus scratching the cornea, causing tearing and infection. It’s in the breed, as are cataracts and dry eye, and it is not recommended breeding to these traits as they can be passed on. Every vet has his own prices but usually it runs 600.00 and up for both eyes. Incidenatlly, one operation doesn’t always work, and sometimes a dog can get from three to four done and if you don’t your dog can go blind. This is a common problem in Chows and Shar-Pei also and any breed with lots of loose skin and heavy brow. No Clumber line is that pure to be totally free of eye problems, and all Clumbers should be CERF’d yearly by a licensed opthamologist.
Response:
Interesting addition to this thread. This thread begand with a man I believe is name was Jason. He was requesting information on obtaining names of Clumber breeders so he could get a breeding pair of “pet quality” Clumbers. He was obviously flamed by many knowledgable people in this group. Anyway, I spoke with a Clumber breeder this morning and even though she does not have acess to the Internet she was well aware of this person. She has some puppies and he tried to obtain some from her. Evidently the red flag has gone up with the clumber breeders so this guy has almost no chance of getting a Clumber. The breeder also told me that he changes where he lives when he calls different breeders. Sometimes it is Missouri, sometimes it is San Diego. Just a word to the wise. George Hejna P.S. thanks for the correction on the entropic/ectropic problem. I always get it mixed up. Good thing I’m not a breeder.
Response:
Excuuuuuse me, people not actually breeding Clumbers eh, guess again. And further more breeding whether last or not is not part of owning a dog. Lots of people are not the least bit interested in breeding and buy dogs for other reasons, such as companionship, hunting, guarding etc., Dogs don’t need to be bred as people don’t need to have kids and the biggest reason for that is responsibility. Just because some of the people on this net aren’t breeding doesn’t mean the rest of the Clumber world isn’t aware of you and your intentions. Maybe you should stick with the Lundhunds they are rarer and you’ll make more progress, but one hour on the phone, a visit to a breeder etc., doesn’t give you the experience and knowledge of owning a Clumber or another breed. And again “pets” aren’t for breeding, and even if you bought a show puppy, it wouldn’t be outright and you will be faced to co-own with contracts up the ying yang and no guarantee of having it bred.
Response:
Then, she could tell you about all of her dogs, especially the one that was #2 clumber spaniel in the United States.
I don’t think you are ever going to get a Clumber, based on my email and posts here. Or maybe you’ll get a retiree who has been neutered. And I really don’t believe that you’re visiting any breeders. The ones here at least wouldn’t even want you to know where they live! breeding clumbers a total of four times. If you cannot see the fact that breeding is last on my list of importance, please stop responding, as I’m getting tired of saying it. I’m merely asking about breeding because it
Oh I’m just getting warmed up! I’m obviously annoying you. What fun! Once again, if you cannot see the fact that breeding is *last* on my list of importance, STOP responding and wasting my time and yours.
See above. You see, I **LIKE** to waste the time of folks like you: I figure any minute you spend here is another one you can’t spend finding a breeder. If you get a chance, I’d really like the email addresses of all those breeders with whom you’ve communicated (or I would like for them to contact me directly, since they are all reading this message thread) , as it would help me immensely in my research. (Especially, since I’ve not received a single message from anyone who actually breed clumbers.)
Doesn’t that tell you something? There are some breeds (Flat-Coat Retrievers also come to mind), where breeders really don’t want to sell to every moron that wanders onto the net. And an initial post such as yours regarding the breeding of pets would so disgust them, that they would instantly close ranks and ignore you. Most would have no interest in trying to educate someone who is so clearly a Neandertal (no insult meant to Neandertals). They know that any info you manage to glean from them may be used in susequent sleziod calls to breeders. So they WANT to keep you dumb and ignorant. They know that by keeping quiet, odds are you will give up and go away, and buy some other breed of dog. One that is sold via a Shake A Paw franchise perhaps. Look, there are plenty of horrible breeders of popular dogs: I am sure there are puppy mills in PA or MO who would be delighted to sell you a pair of Lab or Golden puppies to set up shop with in your backyard. For the price of half a Clumber puppy, and no wait at all, you TOO can breed Golden puppies. What a horrible thought, Mr. I Have Bred Salt Water Fish so I Can Now Breed Clumbers as Pets. Just remember, Shake A Paw will buy everything that can breath at 6 weeks or so. Instant puppy sales!! Twzl & Sligo (who needs 100 channels of cable, when this is so much more fun?) –
Response: